A TINA.org investigation of Gillette found that the company was making the unqualified claim that its product line was made in the United States in a national marketing campaign when the overwhelming majority of products were not entirely made in the United States –most of these products were entirely made in foreign countries, such as China, Poland, Brazil, and Mexico, while others contained non-U.S. components.
- TINA.org sent warning letter to Gillette
- Gillette removed deceptive ads from social media but not TV
- TINA.org filed complaint with FTC
- Gillette aired new, corrected TV commercial
- FTC sent company a closing letter
The FTC sends Gillette a closing letter after raising concerns with the company regarding “certain marketing materials [that] overstated the extent to which Gillette products . . . are made in the United States.” In the letter, the FTC states that Gillette had implemented a remedial action plan that “includes discontinuing unqualified U.S.-origin claims across all shaving and shaving-related products in digital advertising, broadcast advertising, and on packages,” and that the Commission will continue to monitor the company’s advertising closely.
According to Kantar Media, Gillette ceases airing its Boston-centric commercial on national television.
Gillette airs a new national television commercial that, instead of highlighting its Boston factory and showing multiple American flags, states “Invented in Boston. Made and sold around the world.”
TINA.org sends a letter to the FTC regarding Gillette’s ineffective changes to its 30-second national television commercial and urging the Commission to take swift action.
Gillette makes minor edits to its 30-second national television commercial boasting its Boston headquarters, including (1) adding a barely legible disclosure toward the end of the commercial that appears on the screen for approximately two seconds stating “Founded in Boston. Where we still make all premium ProShield, ProGlide, and Fusion5 cartridges.” and (2) replacing the screenshot that originally showed three razors with foreign made handles with a screenshot of three blades it claims are made in Boston.
However, neither of these changes make the deceptive commercial any less misleading. The added disclosure is not clear and conspicuous as is required by law, and the commercial still makes the unqualified implied claim that all Gillette products are made in Boston, which is deceptive because the vast majority of Gillette products are made, in whole or in part, outside the United States.
Due to Gillette’s failure to completely remedy its deceptive Made in Boston campaign, TINA.org files a complaint with the FTC urging it to commence an investigation into the marketing tactics being used by Gillette and take appropriate enforcement action.
December 2017-January 2018
As a result of TINA.org’s warning letter, as well as several subsequent communications between TINA.org and senior counsel for Gillette, the company ultimately removes the majority of its deceptive social media posts, apparently acknowledging the existence of deceptive origin claims in its marketing materials. But Gillette has thus far failed to remove deceptive origin claims from its daily national television commercials – the most visible part of its Made in Boston marketing campaign – or a YouTube video that has been viewed more than 500,000 times.
TINA.org sends warning letter to Procter & Gamble notifying it of TINA.org’s findings regarding Gillette’s Made in Boston marketing campaign, and asking that it remedy the deceptive marketing immediately.
Despite Boston-Made Claims, Many Gillette Products Wicked Imported
TINA.org files FTC complaint over Gillette’s false and deceptive Made in the USA claims.
Williams-Sonoma to Pay $1 Million to Settle Deceptive Ad Lawsuit Sparked by TINA.org
FTC takes action against home goods and kitchenware company for misleading made in the USA claims.
Ad Watchdog TINA.org Petitions FTC for Made in USA Rule
MADISON, CONN. August 22, 2019– Consumer advocacy organization, truthinadvertising.org (TINA.org), filed a formal petition today requesting that the Federal Trade Commission (FTC) use its rulemaking authority to expand its enforcement…
TINA.org’s Made in USA Actions
A review of TINA.org’s work uncovering (and putting an end to) deceptive made in the USA ad campaigns.
Mercedes Slams Brakes on Built in USA Claims after TINA.org Inquiry
TINA.org found the German automaker didn’t have the support to claim its Sprinter van was “built in the USA.”
Gillette Engaged in Deceptive Made in USA Marketing
Ad Watchdog TINA.org Files FTC Complaint MADISON, CONN. January 23, 2018 – Despite a national advertising campaign showcasing patriotic imagery, highlighting its Boston headquarters, and heavily promoting its “Made in…
Gillette’s Implied Made in the USA Claims
The U.S. flag features prominently in this Gillette ad despite the fact that many of its products aren’t “Made in the USA.”
Gillette Shave Club
Depending on how often you shave, this club may leave you razor burned.
Pure by Gillette Shave Cream
Allegations: Falsely marketing products as pure
Warranties on Gillette, Venus, Braun, and Oral-B Products
Allegations: Failing to timely disclose that warranties are conditioned upon using authorized repair services and replacement parts
Gillete® Fusion ProGlide Sensitive 2-in-1 Shave Gel
August 2018: This case was transferred to federal court. (Case No. 18-cv-6844, C.D. Cal.) April 2018: A class-action lawsuit was filed against Procter & Gamble for allegedly misleadingly using You…
Duracell Ultra Advanced and Ultra Power Batteries
March 2016: The U.S. Supreme Court denied An order the U.S. Supreme Court issues to review a lower court’s judgment.. January 2015: TINA.org filed an amicus brief supporting a December…
The Packaging for Gillette® and Old Spice® Deodorants
October 2015: The named plaintiff dismissed this action When a complaint is dismissed without prejudice, an amended version of the complaint can be refiled.. The reasons for the dismissal have…
Duracell Batteries with the Duralock Ring
In March 2016, a federal judge dismissed a class-action lawsuit filed against Gillette and Procter & Gamble alleging that the marketing for Duracell AA and AAA Copper Top batteries with…
In October 2015, a federal judge dismissed a class-action lawsuit against the makers of Duracell batteries alleging, among other things, that the marketing (including TV and radio commercials, and product…
Gillette® and Old Spice® Deodorants
December 2014: The parties agreed to dismiss this lawsuit. The reasons for the dismissal have not yet been disclosed. September 2014: A class-action lawsuit was filed against Procter & Gamble…