TINA.org investigated Mary Kay, a Texas-based multilevel marketing company that sells cosmetics and skincare products, and found that the company and its distributors used deceptive, atypical and unsubstantiated income claims to market the Mary Kay business opportunity.
- Notified company of findings
- Filed complaint with the DSSRC
- DSSRC report found that Mary Kay engaged in deceptive marketing
- Mary Kay removed majority of inappropriate earning claims
The DSSRC issues a second case decision finding that Mary Kay and its distributors continue to use deceptive, atypical and unsubstantiated income claims to market the Mary Kay business opportunity, including the ability to achieve financial freedom and earn a five-figure residual income. The DSSRC determined that Mary Kay made good faith efforts to remove the claims at issue and closed its investigation.
Determining that Mary Kay had removed from publication many of the claims identified by TINA.org, the DSSRC closes its investigation and issues a case report stating that the company and its distributors had indeed been making inappropriate income claims to promote the company’s business opportunity. However, as of the date of the DSSRC’s case report, several deceptive income claims published by Mary Kay and its distributors remained in circulation.
Because the vast majority of the deceptive income claims remain in publication after TINA.org’s communications with Mary Kay, TINA.org files a complaint with the DSSRC urging it to investigate Mary Kay’s deceptive income claims and take action.
Mary Kay responds to TINA.org stating, among other things, that it has reviewed the materials TINA.org brought to its attention and “believe the net impression of the videos and other materials identified in [TINA.org’s] correspondence do not misrepresent the potential of the Mary Kay opportunity.”
After finding an additional 200 examples of unsubstantiated income claims marketing the Mary Kay business opportunity, TINA.org sends another letter to Mary Kay urging the company to remove the claims from publication.
Does Mary Kay Think It’s Above the Law?
MLM making deceptive claims after several warnings.
TINA.org Pushes for New Enforcement Tactic Against MLM Industry
And if you don’t know, now you know.
Mary Kay’s Deceptive Pinky Promises
How MLMs Exploit Consumers During a Pandemic
Deceptive earnings claims edition.
MLM Income Claims
Multilevel Marketing: The Day Job that Doesn’t Pay
More than 97 percent of DSA member companies use or have used misleading income claims.
MLMs Tap College Campuses for Recruits
MLM and pyramid scheme experts say more must be done to educate and raise student awareness.