Apple Intelligence
Allegations: Falsely marketing when AI features would be available on iPhones
The Functionality of Apple iPhones
March 2016: A federal judge dismissed this action finding that plaintiffs did not satisfy the heightened-pleading standard for fraud-based claims and did not state a plausible claim. The dismissal was When a complaint is dismissed with prejudice, it cannot be refiled..
May 2015: Plaintiffs filed another complaint making similar allegations.
March 2015: A federal judge dismissed a false advertising class-action lawsuit against Apple. The complaint, which was originally filed in 2014, alleged, among other things, that the functionality of Apple’s iPhone 4, iPhone 4s, and iPhone 5 was reduced after installing the iOS 7 update. According to the plaintiffs, the company misleadingly represented the abilities and capabilities of the iPhones – including their ability to wirelessly download features and apps from new versions of iOS, and their Wi-Fi and Bluetooth connection capabilities – because the iPhones did not perform as advertised after the iOS 7 update was downloaded. The judge dismissed the complaint for two reasons: First, the named plaintiff did not specify one misrepresentation that he viewed, or where and when he viewed it; and second, the named plaintiff did not plead that he actually relied on a misrepresentation when making the purchase. The judge dismissed the complaint without prejudice, meaning that the complaint can be refiled. (Yastrab et al v. Apple Inc., Case No. 14-cv-1974, N. D. CA.)
For more information about other class-action lawsuits filed against Apple and TINA.org’s coverage of the company, click here.
Class-Action Tracker
Apple’s Siri
Allegations: Misrepresenting that Siri devices only listen to, record, and share conversations if users provide consent when the company intercepted, recorded, disclosed, and misused consumers’ private conversations without their consent
AirPods Max
Allegations: Marketing that products provide “unparalleled wireless audio” when a defect causes condensation that leads to several performance issues
Apple Watch
Allegations: Marketing products as safe when wearers may suffer injuries
Apple Watch Series 9, Apple Watch SE (2nd generation), and Apple Watch Ultra 2
Allegations: Falsely marketing products as “carbon neutral”
Apps from Apple’s App Store
Allegations: Misrepresenting that apps from Apple’s app store have been vetted and reviewed, are safe and secure, and comply with applicable laws
Apple Watch Sport Band, Ocean Band, and Nike Sport Band
Allegations: Falsely advertising products as designed for human health, environmental sustainability, and everyday use
Powerbeats Pro Headphones
Allegations: Marketing that headphones provide “up to 9 hours listening time,” charging cases provide “more than 24 hours listening time,” and devices provide continuous Bluetooth connectivity when they fail to…
The Security of Communications on iPhones
Allegations: Misleadingly marketing that iMessage and Facetime are secure methods of communication without disclosing that a flaw in Apple’s iOS software and T-Mobile’s SIM card practices allow iMessage correspondence and…
iPhones at Target
Allegations: Falsely advertising that phones are unlocked
Apple AirPods Pro Gen 1
Allegations: Misleadingly marketing products as providing superior audio and having noise-cancelling features
Apple’s iOS update
Allegations: Misrepresenting that an iOS update was compatible with older devices
Apple iPhones
Allegations: Failing to adequately disclose that products do not come with power adapters needed to charge devices
Powerbeats Headphones
Allegations: Deceptively marketing Powerbeats headphones as “BUILT TO ENDURE” and the “BEST HEADPHONES FOR WORKING OUT”
Apple’s Subscriptions for iCloud Storage
Allegations: Misleadingly representing that owners of Apple devices who purchase iCloud subscriptions get the storage in the plan plus the 5GB of storage automatically provided to all owners of Apple…
AppleCare and AppleCare+ Plans
Allegations: Misrepresenting that replacement devices under warranties will be new devices when they are actually refurbished, reconditioned, and secondhand
Apple Watches
Allegations: Misleadingly representing that the wristwatch is capable of measuring blood oxygen levels when the device does not provide accurate measurements
iOS Software Updates for iPhone 4s
Allegations: Misleadingly representing that the iOS 9 software was compatible with and would improve the performance of the iPhone 4s when the update slowed down the performance of phones and…
Apple’s Privacy Controls
Allegations: Falsely representing that Apple will not collect data about consumers’ activity in apps if they turn off certain privacy settings
Beats Powerbeats Pro Wireless Earbud Headphones
Allegations: Misleadingly marketing Beats Powerbeats Pro wireless earbuds
Apple Watch SE
Allegations: Falsely marketing smart watches as “swimproof” and water resistant when they’re not
Gambling Games in Apple’s App Store
Allegations: Promoting illegal virtual gambling games
Casino Gambling Games in Apple’s App Store
Allegations: Promoting illegal virtual gambling games
Virtual Casino Games on Apple
Allegations: Promoting illegal virtual gambling games
Disclosures in Apple’s App Store
Allegations: Using ratings categories that fail to disclose that certain games use loot boxes
Apple’s iCloud Storage
Allegations: Misleadingly representing that it would provide subscribers with iCloud storage when their data was stored on cloud servers owned by other entities
The Performance of Apple Devices
Allegations: Failing to disclose that devices unexpectedly power off due to a defect and an update resulted in reduced processing speeds and other operations
Digital Content from iTunes
Allegations: Misleadingly marketing that consumers can “buy” digital content when Apple does not own all of the content it sells and must revoke access to content if its license to…
DoubleU Games in Apple’s App Store
Allegations: Promoting illegal virtual gambling games
iPhone XR
Allegations: Failing to disclose that the iPhone XR has only half of the connectivity and 4G speed of the iPhone XS and iPhone XS Max
iPhone’s Water-Resistant Claims
Allegations: Misleadingly marketing phones as water resistant without clarifying the difference between water-proof and water-resistant
Digital Content Purchased from Apple
Allegations: Misleadingly representing that consumers may “buy” content by paying a higher price when Apple may revoke consumers’ access to “purchased” content at any time and for any reason
Screens of iPhone X, iPhone XS, and iPhone XS Max
MacBook Pro Laptops with Touch Bars
Storage Capacity of Apple Devices with the iOS 8 Operating System
2nd Generation Apple AirPods
Apple Chargers for the iPhone 7
Apple’s Subscriptions to Digital Content
2018’s Apple Shopping Event
Season Bundles of TV Shows on Apple iTunes
Apple’s Powerbeats Headphones
The Security of Information on iDevices
iPhone 4s and the iOS 9 Operating System
Apple iMac
The iTunes “Season Pass” of Breaking Bad Season 5
AppleCare Warranty
Apple’s Wi-Fi Assist Application
Apple’s iPhone Upgrade Program
Apple iPhone 5 Wi-Fi Signals
Apple’s Siri
Advertised Storage Capacity of Apple Devices
The Latest
You Bought the Movie on iTunes. But It’s Not Yours.
Surrender your iTunes movies.
Ad or Not? Snapchat and DJ Khaled
Is DJ Khaled the key endorser on Snapchat?
iPhone Trade-in
Fine print discloses numerous conditions tied to new iPhone promotion.
Ad or Not? Oscars Edition
Paid endorsement or uncompensated editorial content? These celeb social media posts are tough to tell.
Apple Accused of Misleading Consumers about iPhone Storage
How much storage space do consumers really have?