
Prairie Farms Premium Vanilla Ice Cream
Allegations: Misleadingly marketing ice cream as vanilla when the flavor comes from synthetic ingredients
In January 2020, a class-action lawsuit was filed against Prairie Farms Dairy for allegedly misleadingly marketing that Prairie Farms Premium Vanilla Bean Ice Creams are flavored exclusively with vanilla beans when, according to the complaint, the ingredients list shows that the ice creams also contain unspecified “natural flavor.” Plaintiffs also claim that the company likely uses “exhausted” vanilla beans to make the ice creams look more like the flavor comes from vanilla even though the beans do not add any flavor to the product because they have had all of the flavor extracted from them. (Darby et al v. Prairie Farms Dairy, Inc., Case No. 20-cv-151, S. D. NY.)
For more of TINA.org’s coverage of vanilla products, click here.
Allegations: Misleadingly marketing ice cream as vanilla when the flavor comes from synthetic ingredients
MADISON, CONN. Sept. 9, 2025 – An investigation by consumer advocacy organization truthinadvertising.org (TINA.org) has found that Homeaglow is deceptively advertising $19 home cleanings in order to lure consumers into…
TINA.org files complaint against home cleaning platform with FTC, states.
Lawsuits aren’t giving any slack when it comes to underfilled packages.
Why advertise a price that no consumer will pay?
Watch out for online retailers’ bait-and-switch tactics.