Week in Review

| Bonnie Patten

Oil, heating pads, rugs, razors, and drinks – no, this isn’t about preparing for a romantic interlude, but rather the products featured in the I-think-you’re-lying-to-me category during the week of February 18, 2013.


  • If a product is made with genetically modified organisms (GMOs) can it still be marketed as “all natural”?  Not according to the plaintiffs who sued J.M. Smuckers this past week alleging that its oils – Crisco Natural Blend Oil, Crisco Pure Corn Oil, Crisco Pure Canola Oil, and Crisco Pure Vegetable Oil –are deceptively marketed as “all natural” when they contain GMOs.
  • Much to the chagrin of supplement maker Supple LLC, a lawsuit against it got the green light to proceed as a big old class action.  The case claims that Supple falsely advertises its beverage as being clinically proven to help treat joint pain when, in reality, the drink is no more effective than a placebo.


  • Kaz USA Inc. will pay between $1.45 and $2.7 million to settle a class-action lawsuit, which claimed Kaz deceptively labeled and advertised its electronic heating pads by not telling users that the pads could burn them if used in certain ways.  Before you get too excited, the settlement stipulates that the most a class member can receive is $20. Oh, but don’t worry because the plaintiffs’ lawyers can collect up to $1.5 million in fees. Now that’s a burn.


  • The Rug Doctor vs. Bissell: these companies compete in the home carpet cleaning machine rental business.  Each complained to NAD (the investigative unit of the advertising industry’s system of self-regulation) that the other was being mean to them by dissing their products in broadcast, Internet, and/or print advertising.  I will spare you the dirty details and simply say that NAD found their products were pretty much equal in performance.
  • Schick vs. Gillette: the maker of Schick razors was feeling chaffed over Gillette’s advertising claims that its Venus & Olay women’s razors help replenish skin’s moisture, so Schick took its complaint to NAD. NAD recommended that Gillette stop making advertising claims that suggest shaving with Venus & Olay would provide benefits beyond just lubricating skin while shaving.

Bonnie Patten

Bonnie, executive director of, is an attorney and mother of three. Her commitment to educating the public about deceptive marketing stems from her belief that education is the only…

See More Posts

You Might Be Interested In