Phoebe Gates’s Startup Phia Was Just Accused of ‘Cookie Stuffing.’ Here’s What Happens Next
Esther Lian, Inc.com
Dodgion et al. v. J.R. Watkins, LLC
26-cv-2604, N.D. Cal.
(March 2026)
J.R. Watkins soaps and cleaning products
Falsely marketing products as “All Natural” when they contain several artificial ingredients, including methylisothiazolinone, sodium benzoate, potassium sorbate, and citric acid
Pending
Esther Lian, Inc.com
Georgia Fearn, Inc.com
Lawsuits attempt to clear the air.
You can’t replace the human spark. People truly are the best.
These “waterless” beauty products contain some surprising ingredients.